Current:Home > InvestColorado judge strikes down Trump’s attempt to toss a lawsuit seeking to bar him from the ballot-LoTradeCoin
Colorado judge strikes down Trump’s attempt to toss a lawsuit seeking to bar him from the ballot
View Date:2024-12-23 22:48:30
DENVER (AP) — A Colorado judge has rejected an attempt by former President Donald Trump to dismiss a lawsuit that seeks to keep him off the state ballot, ruling that his objections on free-speech grounds did not apply.
Trump’s attorneys argued that a Colorado law protecting people from being sued over exercising their free speech rights shielded him from the lawsuit, but Colorado District Judge Sarah Wallace said that law doesn’t apply in this case.
The law also conflicted with a state requirement to get the question about Trump’s eligibility resolved quickly — before a Jan. 5 deadline for presidential candidates’ names to certified for the Colorado primary, Wallace wrote.
Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington claims in its lawsuit that putting Trump on the ballot in Colorado would violate a provision of the 14th Amendment that bars people who have “engaged in insurrection” against the Constitution from holding office.
The group’s chief counsel, Donald K. Sherman, welcomed Wallace’s decision, which was made late Wednesday. He called it a “well-reasoned and very detailed order” in a statement Thursday. A Denver-based attorney for Trump, Geoffrey Blue, didn’t immediately return a phone message Thursday seeking comment.
The Colorado case is one of several involving Trump that stand to test the Civil War-era constitutional amendment, which has never been ruled on by the U.S. Supreme Court. Along with lawsuits filed in Minnesota and Michigan, it has a good chance of reaching the nation’s high court.
The lawsuits also involve one of Trump’s arguments in criminal cases filed against him in Washington, D.C., and Georgia for his attempt to overturn his 2020 loss — that he is being penalized for engaging in free speech to disagree with the validity of the vote tally.
The Colorado case will focus in part on the meaning of “insurrection” under the 14th Amendment, whether it applies only to waging war on the U.S. or can apply to Trump’s goading of a mob that attacked the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, to halt the certification of President Joe Biden’s win.
Trump’s attorneys dispute that it applies to his attempt to undo the election results. They also assert that the 14th Amendment requires an act of Congress to be enforced and that it doesn’t apply to Trump, anyway.
Trump swore a presidential oath to “preserve, protect and defend” the Constitution, but the text of the 14th Amendment says it applies to those who have sworn oaths to “support” the Constitution, Blue pointed out the sematic difference in an Oct. 6 filing in the case.
Both oaths “put a weighty burden on the oath-taker,” but those who wrote the amendment were aware of the difference, Blue argued.
“The framers of the 14th Amendment never intended for it to apply to the President,” he wrote.
The trial to determine Trump’s eligibility for the Colorado ballot is scheduled to start Oct. 30.
___
Gruver reported from Cheyenne, Wyoming.
veryGood! (52)
Related
- 'Dangerous and unsanitary' conditions at Georgia jail violate Constitution, feds say
- Girl, 11, dies after vehicle crashes into tree in California. 5 other young teens were injured
- Kroger and Albertsons head to court to defend merger plan against US regulators’ objections
- German police say 26-year-old man has turned himself in, claiming to be behind Solingen knife attack
- Why Dolly Parton Is a Fan of Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce's Little Love Affair
- Columbus Crew vs. Los Angeles FC Leagues Cup final: How to watch Sunday's championship
- Fair-goers scorched by heartland heat wave take refuge under misters as some schools let out early
- 'This is our division': Brewers run roughshod over NL Central yet again
- Jennifer Lopez Gets Loud in Her First Onstage Appearance Amid Ben Affleck Divorce
- Kelly Ripa Reacts to Daughter Lola Consuelos Posting “Demure” Topless Photo
Ranking
- Week 10 fantasy football rankings: PPR, half-PPR and standard leagues
- Water Issues Confronting Hikers on the Pacific Crest Trail Trickle Down Into the Rest of California
- Flights for life: Doctor uses plane to rescue hundreds of dogs from high-kill shelters
- Hailey and Justin Bieber reveal birth of first baby: See the sweet photo
- How Saturday Night Live Reacted to Donald Trump’s Win Over Kamala Harris
- Hone downgraded to tropical storm as it passes Hawaii; all eyes on Hurricane Gilma
- Trump is expected to tie Harris to chaotic Afghanistan War withdrawal in speech to National Guard
- Timeline of Gateway Church exodus, allegations following claims against Robert Morris
Recommendation
-
Mike Tyson employs two trainers who 'work like a dream team' as Jake Paul fight nears
-
Daughter of ex-MLB pitcher Greg Swindell reported missing, multi-state search underway
-
Search continues for woman missing after Colorado River flash flood at Grand Canyon National Park
-
Can dogs see color? The truth behind your pet's eyesight.
-
Messi breaks silence on Inter Miami's playoff exit. What's next for his time in the US?
-
Legendary USA TODAY editor Bob Dubill dies: 'He made every newsroom better'
-
Kelly Ripa Reacts to Daughter Lola Consuelos Posting “Demure” Topless Photo
-
Tusk says he doesn’t have the votes in parliament to liberalize Poland’s strict abortion law